• The Power Up
  • Posts
  • šŸ”‹ šŸ§‘ā€šŸŽØ šŸ¤– The Power Up #73: Creativity in an AI World

šŸ”‹ šŸ§‘ā€šŸŽØ šŸ¤– The Power Up #73: Creativity in an AI World

Is Generative AI good or bad for human creativity?

A few weeks ago I attended a talk by Elizabeth Gilbert, the world-renowned author, journalist, podcaster and creator of creativity bible Big Magic: Creative Living Beyond Fear (as well as novels Eat, Pray, Love and City of Girls among many other things). 

The majority of Lizā€™s heartfelt and sage message centred upon the subtle but profound distinction between forgiveness and mercy. However, there was also plenty of time to discuss the topic with which she has become indelibly linked: Creativity. And a particular quote stuck with me:

ā€œThe creative life is not about being an artist.
It is one of curiosity.ā€

It got me thinking about the current debate about whether or not Generative AI can or will replace human creativity that generally presents a spectrum whereby, at one extreme, the days of human artists are numbered. If a machine can create something in an instant that is visually striking and communicates a message, yet it would take hours, days or weeks for a human to fulfil the same brief, then frankly, who has the time to wait for (or the will to pay) the human?

This view tends to be popular amongst the tech community who see the world through feature lists, some less brand-savvy marketing & sales people who ā€œjust need some content fast for this social media or email campaign,ā€ and finance directors who have been persistently trying to cut spending on creatives for years.

At the other end of the spectrum are those who hold that human creativity is sacred, and that machines can never come close to the sanctity of human creative expression.

And then thereā€™s a whole savannah of blurry middle where the curiosity that Liz Gilbert speaks of comes into play. This is one area where Iā€™m optimistic that the AI revolution can help us enter a new golden age of creativity.

If we see a creative life as not just making art, but also being curious, exploring ideas, connecting them, and using new tools to express ourselves in fresh ways, then Generative AI can boost and expand human creativity.

AI can give us access to and understanding of ideas and concepts, old and new. Already weā€™ve seen that image generation tools like Midjourney have sparked renewed interest in Art History, as its users seek to learn about classic artistic styles of the past to influence new expressions today.

Generative AI lets us try out different ways of expressing ourselves. We can find styles we like by experimenting, something that used to be possible only for professional artists or people with a lot of free time.

I believe that, ultimately, this combination of human curiosity, imagination and experimentation enabled by technology will give birth to new and as yet hard-to-conceive-of forms of expression.

Can AI-generated art be considered as ā€˜valuableā€™ as purely human-generated art? Well, thatā€™s open to debate. I would argue that we should still place a high premium on the years of graft, craft and experience it takes a human to create an artefact that can stop its beholders in their tracks, feel something deeply, and learn something about humanity.

But that doesnā€™t mean that humans experimenting with new AI tools is not also a creative act.

What do you think?

Poll: What's your opinion on generative AI & Creativity?

Select from one of the three options below - and leave your thoughts when prompted to have a chance of being featured in the next edition.

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

In issue #72 we asked for your opinion on AI companions:
67% of you were generally in favour of AI companions, given that they offer an environment where people can experiment with different identities, develop social skills, get coached, share things they can't elsewhere, or find comfort in times of emotional hardship.

ā€œAI-assisted coaching and therapy is probably better than no - or incompetent - coaching and therapy,ā€œ added Laura May.

Introducing: Innovation in Sport

If you like The Power Up, you'll love my new newsletter, Innovation in Sport.

I believe that sport is a powerful driver of commnection, community, health, wellbeing & purpose. IIS is my lens on the latest trends, innovations and activations that are shaping how we participate in and enjoy sport & esports.

Please subscribe below for free.

Innovation in SportRounding up the very latest in sport technology, creativity, experience, impact, community & more.

Created by Sora from OpenAI

The New Creatorsā€™ Toolbox

If youā€™re new to creating with Generative AI here are my top recommendations for the most useful AI-powered creative tools available today:

For all-round Creative Studio capabilities: Canva

Canva last week unveiled a host of new AI-powered capabilities in its updated ā€˜Magic Studioā€™, including Magic Design for Video, Magic Edit, Magic Grab and the ability to integrate a wide range of third-party AI apps like Dall:E, music generation tool MelodyMuse and QR code generator Hello QArt within its already extremely user-friendly and cost-effective platform.

Iā€™d go as far as to say that Canva is an essential must-have tool in any wannabe creatorā€™s arsenal.

For Image Generation: Midjourney

Yes, there are many, many other AI text-to-image generators, but for me, after a bit of practice with prompting, the image results from Midjourney look the most striking and convincing.

For Audio Generation: Suno

In the past few months, several tools like Suno have popped up enabling anybody with an idea and a prompt to create passable songs in any musical style. It may be a copyright timebomb waiting to explode, but itā€™s a lot of fun and has practical use cases as an alternative to content-backing tracks.

For Video Generation: Runway

Youā€™ve doubtless seen the teaser content from OpenAIā€™s text-to-video tool Sora. And indeed, Google have teased a very similar product called Veo. But neither are available to the masess yet, so for now, the leader of the AI-generated video field is Runway. From a single prompt you can generate a 4 second video, then you can choose to extend your shot up to a total of 16 seconds.

I deliberately gave you just my top recommendations in each key category rather than an overwhelming, all-encompassing list. But if you want a fuller list, you can also find that here.

The Creator's ToolboxA weekly roundup of news, tools, and resources for creatives.

In this article, Harvard Business Review shows a wide range of practical examples of how Generative AI can be used throughout the creative process. For example, supporting in divergent thinking, challenging human cognitive biases, assisting in detailed idea evaluation and helping in idea refinement.

What does ChatGPT itself think about the impacts of AI in the creative fields? Researchers asked the large language model for its point of view and it came back with 50 compelling risks - including homogenisation of art, cognitive loss in human learners, amplification of bias and loss of cultural heritage. Do the positives outweigh such a worrying collection of negatives?

This report explores practical, evidence-based tools to boost imaginative thinking: Meditation practices like open monitoring, focused attention, and non-sleep deep rest (NSDR), as well as how dopamine levels, influenced by mood, diet, and supplements, can foster creativity.

It also covers tips on behavioural and nutritional strategies to enhance dopamine. And how movement, storytelling, and certain substances can spark creativity.

Drawing from neuroscience, psychology, and philosophy, these strategies aim to expand your imaginative capabilities for various aspects of life.

Maybe itā€™s not artificial intelligence we need to improve our thinking, but more strolling? From the works of Charles Darwin to Virginia Woolf and Henry David Thoreau, the writer looks at the walking habits of some of historyā€™s greatest writers.

The Creative Act: A Way of Being, by Rick Rubin  

Legendary music producer Rick Rubin captures his lifeā€™s musings on creativity in this inspiring magnum opus of a book. Rubin argues that creativity has a place in everyone's life, and everyone can make that place larger. In fact, there are few more important responsibilities.

The Creative Act is a beautiful and generous study that illuminates the path of the artist as a road we all can follow.

Big Magic: Creative Living Beyond Fear, by Elizabeth Gilbert

Elizabeth Gilbert shares her unique understanding of creativity and the creative process.

Sharing stories from her own life, Gilbert challenges readers to embrace curiosity, pursue what we love and face down our fears.

Why fill your head with negative news every day?

Escape the negative news cycle, and subscribe to a positive mindset, by subscribing to The Uplifting Inbox.

The Uplifting TimesInsights, Good News, and Big Ideas for Daily Life.

Will the use of AI in creative work lead to a sanintised, homogenous sensory experience where everything feels the same? Are we heading for a Matrix-like corporate dullness?

The team from the Celebrating Cinema podcast from Lab111 in Amsterdam explore representations of AI in the movies.

How to decide which creative ideas to pursue

With a constant flow of ideas and limited time to explore them, how do we choose which to pursue?

When we choose poorly, we drown in half-finished projects, wasted time, inefficiency, and regrets.

But we can tilt the odds of choosing the right ideas to pursue in our favour if we follow a few guidelines.

Video: Fredrik Backman on Creative Anxiety and Procrastination

In this laugh-out-loud 4:41 min speech, Fredrik Backman discusses the highs and lows of being an author, from attempting to get along with the voices in your brain, to the hidden joys of jet lag.

ā

The creative life is an amplified life. Itā€™s a bigger life, a happier life, an expanded life, and a hell of a lot more interesting life.

Elizabeth Gilbert

Enjoyed this issue?
Please share it with a friend.

I hope you found something valuable in this edition of The Power Up. If you did, I'd really appreciate it if you were to forward this email to a friend who might find it interesting or helpful.  

And if you've received this from a friend, and would like to receive it regularly, you can sign-up here.

See you next time, Adam

Gif by jasperai on Giphy